Active reading starts before the first page. Note what you expect the book to argue, then mark the sentences that test that expectation.
Marginalia are most useful when they are short: a question, a counterexample, or a link to something you already know. Keep the notes in one place so the connections accumulate across books.
Volume retention comes from returning. Revisit each title after a week with a single prompt: what changed in your thinking, and what would you now argue against?